The stage was set for Alicia Keys’ surprise performance Sunday in the Super Bowl halftime show to be memorable, cameras gradually closing in to show the singer seated at a red grand piano, wearing a red dress with a huge matching and glimmering cape behind her. But as she began her 2003 hit “If I Ain’t Got You,” and the cape floated away, Keys endured a stumble that clashed with the grandness of the moment: Her voice cracked. The snag didn’t escape attention; reviewers and online posters pointed it out. But that was Sunday. Early Monday, the NFL posted the show on its YouTube page, the Washington Post reports, and in that version, Keys’ vocal is perfectly smooth.
Social media posts put the two versions side by side, per Variety. Representatives of the NFL, sponsor Apple Music, and Keys did not respond to requests for comment. But her husband, music producer Swizz Beatz, reacted sharply. “Y’all talking about the wrong damn thing,” he posted on Instagram, adding, “We don’t do negative vibes on this side we make history.” The NFL’s better-than-live version can be found here. (More Super Bowl halftime stories.)